It often occurs that a large insured loss will also result in a significant uninsured (as opposed to underinsured) loss. For example, when a loss covered under a policy of property insurance also results in an uninsured loss of rental income.
When this happens, disputes can arise between the Insured and the Insurer as to which of them has conduct of the action. In the absence of any specific policy provision, the general rule is that the parties are entitled to separate representation to protect their interests, although the Court will not permit two sets of solicitors to appear on the record, and is even less likely to allow the Claimant to recover two sets of solicitors’ costs.
In practice the party with the larger loss will usually take the lead in the action.
In circumstances where there is a mixture of insured and uninsured losses, and the Insurer has conduct of the action, the Insurer will usually pay the costs of advancing the subrogated claim, but will require a contribution to the legal costs associated with the claim for the uninsured losses.
In such cases it is important to agree early on how any recovery will be distributed. This is because a global settlement offer which does not apportion the settlement sum between the individual heads of claim can cause tension between Insured and Insurer, especially when certain heads of claim are perceived to be more speculative than others.
Invariably the Insurer will argue that the balance of the recovery should go to the easily provable material damage claim, say, and not to the more abstract claim for consequential losses. A prior agreement will avoid these disputes and assist in the sensible appraisal of settlement offers.
You can be confident with Edwin Coe that they are experts in their area.
Chambers Directory 2014
Michael Whitton attracts praise from peers, who note - He is extremely experienced, a tough negotiator and very good at ...
Chambers Directory 2015
Both Michael Whitton and Roger Franklin are highly regarded; they know all the tactics, and have an excellent bedside ma ...
Legal 500 2013 (Insurance litigation: for policyholders)
Blog - 09/02/2018
Cladding — Fire prevention and bringing our buildings up to standard
Press Releases - 17/11/2017
Kate Dwyer recommended in The Legal 500 2017 for Insurance L...
Press Releases - 08/11/2017
Nicola Maher now ranked in Chambers UK Band 3 for Insurance
Press Coverage - 23/10/2017
Third parties rights against insurers: old versus new
Events - 10/10/2017 - 11/10/2017
Head of Insurance Litigation, Roger Franklin speaks at Compa...
Blog - 03/08/2017
Contemporaneous evidence and Mike Ashley: what goes down must come up
Blog - 16/06/2017
The Financial Ombudsman: Unreasonably reasonable or reasonably unreaso...
Blog - 14/06/2017
The British Airways IT Failure – Do you have Cyber Insurance?